A 101-step tree beats a 1,010-step one, and the market charges extra for falls
This page answers three questions about vanilla options (standard calls and puts). How does the price react when the market moves? Which binomial tree is more accurate? What does the market charge for protection against a fall?
European option, Black-Scholes-Merton
Saved result, default settings
The live model will load here
This call is worth 8.53, all of it time value.
Table of this chart
| Spot | Value | Intrinsic value |
|---|
Table of this chart
| Spot | Delta | Gamma | Vega |
|---|
Two binomial trees compared
At these settings, 21 Leisen-Reimer steps beat 1,281 Cox-Ross-Rubinstein steps.
Table of this chart
| Steps | Cox-Ross-Rubinstein error | Leisen-Reimer error |
|---|
The Cox-Ross-Rubinstein tree gets closer to the exact price as you add steps, but not smoothly. Adding steps can increase the error. The position of the tree’s end points around the strike changes with the number of steps, and this causes its jagged line. At the default settings it lands almost on the exact price at 1,044 steps, by chance.
The Leisen-Reimer tree is built so that the strike always falls midway between the two central end points. Its line is straight and twice as steep.
The volatility smile of SPY options
At 57 days, a put struck 5% below the forward trades at 17.5% of implied volatility, against 13.7% at the money.
Option chain of 4 November 2026. Days are counted from that date.
| Expiry | Days | Strikes | At-the-money vol | Vol 5% below the forward |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 Nov | 2 | 142 | 15.5% | 27.4% |
| 20 Nov | 16 | 167 | 14.1% | 19.4% |
| 31 Dec | 57 | 299 | 13.7% | 17.5% |
Reading the smile
Implied volatility falls as the strike rises, from the lowest puts to a strike 2% to 7% above the forward, so puts with low strikes cost more. A common explanation is that many investors want protection and few want to sell it. Beyond that point the curve turns up, most of all on the 2-day expiry, but those calls cost one or two cents, so their implied volatility is mostly tick size. The slope is steeper for the shortest expiry and flatter for the later ones.
I use only out-of-the-money options (options that would pay nothing if exercised today): puts below the forward and calls above it. I compute the forward from the spot, the interest rate and the dividend yield. An option that is deep in the money hardly reacts to volatility, so a one-tick error (the smallest price step) in its price moves the implied volatility by several points. With the whole chain, implied volatility on the 57-day expiry jumps by up to 40 points from one strike to the next, for no economic reason.
The smile is also the weak point of the autocall page. That model uses one flat volatility, while its capital barrier sits far down the expensive left side of this curve. So the model makes the note look better than it is.
What I could not show
The SPY volatilities are approximations. SPY options can be exercised early, and the fund pays dividends on set dates. I treat the options as European, with a fixed interest rate of 4.2% and a fixed dividend yield of 1.2%. The forward that separates puts from calls comes from those two numbers. I did not measure it from the market. The effect is largest for the shortest expiries.
The chain is a snapshot from 4 November 2026. It has three expiries: 6 November, 20 November and 31 December. Days are counted from the date of the chain, so an expiry may have passed by the time you read this. The page shows the shape of the smile, and these are not prices you could trade. Of the 696 quotes, 569 are the middle of the bid-offer spread (the gap between the buying and selling price) and 127 are last trades up to four days old. The chart and table use the 608 within 30% of the forward.
No arbitrage checks and no fitted surface. I did not test the chain for arbitrage (prices that would allow a riskless profit), and I did not fit a smooth curve through it.
The full source and 32 tests are at github.com/Nicolas8330/option-pricer.